The Story of The Stranglers is more twisted than you thought

The Stranglers were so punk that the punks hated them. They refused to play by punk’s rules, and found massive success because of it.
So how did a band that didn’t quite fit become one of the defining sounds of the era?
Their biggest hit, Golden Brown, is a perfect demonstration of how The Stranglers forged their own path within the punk landscape. More on that song later.
To their fans, The Stranglers are punk royalty, or even just rock royalty, seeing as they've expanded far beyond your basic punk limits.
But to others, they've been labelled all sorts of things over the years, including misogynists, racists, bullies and smackheads. They really earned themselves a pretty bad reputation, thanks to years of bad behaviour.
If it wasn't their songs offending people, it would be something else. Like starting fights at shows or inciting riots. They even got themselves kicked out of Sweden twice, which does make you wonder why they let them back in the first place.
But aside from all this, there was a lot of genuine musical brilliance. They rewrote what punk could be, and, to be honest, I'm not sure they can even really be called punk. After all, they could play more than three chords, and even manage a melody.
Take Golden Brown, for example. It may be a song about heroin, and possibly a girl, but you wouldn't exactly call it punk, would you? It's got a harpsichord on it!
And that's a really important point to hammer home. While they shared the aggression and attitude of the punk scene, they refused to play by its rules.
Unlike many early punk bands, The Stranglers were older, more experienced musicians who arrived with a sound that already drew from pub rock, psychedelia, progressive music and darker textures. While many punk bands relied on simple, guitar-driven songs, The Stranglers used prominent keyboards, more complex musicianship, longer instrumental sections and a style that often felt more cynical and atmospheric than raw or rebellious.

And that complex sound was largely down to two very clever people: Dave Greenfield and Jean-Jacques Burnel. Greenfield was a keyboard genius who, according to Burnel, was autistic without knowing it. JJ, meanwhile, was an underrated songwriter and bass player, posing as an anarchist – or perhaps just being an anarchist.
The Stranglers started out in England in 1974. Drummer Jet Black had previously owned an ice cream business, which he actually sold to start a band.
In the beginning, they were more closely aligned with punk, playing more straightforward, aggressive songs. And, of course, the UK punk scene was taking off at the time.
They even appeared on the same bill as The Ramones in 1976 at the Roundhouse in London. That gig is often seen as a catalyst for the UK punk explosion. In the audience were members of The Clash, the Sex Pistols and The Damned. You can see where that led.
The Stranglers, however, stayed on their own course. They weren't The Clash or the Sex Pistols. They had a keyboard player, which many punks considered sacrilege. They didn't care. He brought something to the music – in fact, he brought a hell of a lot.
Hugh Cornwell famously said that Greenfield's keyboards were what set The Stranglers apart from every other punk band.
They also had a surprisingly wide range of influences. JJ had played classical guitar in orchestras, Black's background was in jazz, and Cornwell was a blues guy. Greenfield was a military child who had grown up playing bases all over Germany. They were a bit of a mismatch, to say the least.
And they were busy. They released their first three albums in just 13 months, which is pretty ridiculous.
Rattus Norvegicus, No More Heroes and Black and White were all successful, and together they show just how much The Stranglers developed in a very short space of time.
The first two albums were definitely in the pub rock and punk rock mould, but even then, there were hints of their musical abilities.
Peaches, from Rattus Norvegicus, is one of the best examples and one of their early classics. The bass is the main hook, and JJ was actually inspired by reggae music.
The band had attended a reggae gig hosted by their record label, and Burnel was blown away by the way the bass dominated the sound. Speaking to Guitar World in February 2023, he explained:
I'd never heard bass so dominant and I thought, ‘I'm going to write a song like that' and the next day I wrote Peaches.
Funny thing about JJ: he wasn't really a bass player when he joined The Stranglers. He got involved with the band after picking up a hitchhiker, who introduced him to singer Hugh Cornwell and drummer Jet Black.
Cornwell sat him down and suggested they start a band, selling him his Fender bass for £35. Now he had to learn how to play the thing.
Burnel told Guitar World in February 2023:
I knew about melody but I didn't know much about bass playing, so I just made the rules up as I went along. Did that develop my style? Definitely, ‘cos I hadn't listened to many bass players before that.
And this is the thing. As my viewer Mark quite rightly pointed out, JJ became one of the most influential bass players of the punk and post-punk scene. And a lot of it came from simply improvising, or even competing with the other members of the band.
JJ has said that they used to jam and compete with one another, each trying to make their instrument stand out. Hugh had his guitar, Dave had his keyboards, and JJ wanted to stand out too. Meanwhile, Jet, with his jazz background, would be playing all sorts of unusual tempos.
That's part of why The Stranglers' music came out sounding so complex and experimental. Half the time, they were all trying to shine individually and somehow meeting in the middle.
And that Peaches bass hook is literally three notes. It's not complicated, but it had a massive tone and put the bass right at the front of the song. Combined with the keyboards, it was something different. No one in punk was really doing that.
And it made a mark. Peter Hook of Joy Division, in particular, has cited The Stranglers as an influence.
Their second album, No More Heroes, contains one of their most successful UK singles: the title track. The lyrics are definitely punk-tinged, asking what happened to all the heroes.
But the music? That's barely punk at all. It's got a simple, boppy bassline, but the keyboards over the top turn it into something else entirely.
It's really one of their classic albums. They took the bleak, anti-establishment sentiments of Rattus Norvegicus and polished them up a bit, working on their songwriting and funky arrangements. No More Heroes felt like a version of Rattus that clicked even better.

Fans were beginning to notice that they had some pretty proggy elements to their music. These albums are remembered as the more aggressive ones, but there were already signs of what was to come.
And that brings us to Black and White, which marked quite a shift in their sound.
Much more experimental, it's now often regarded as an early post-punk masterpiece. In some ways, The Stranglers were doing it before bands like Joy Division.
The album was full of experimentation, with unusual synth sounds and edited voice recordings. It had songs about robots, and even included a track called Sweden, sung in Swedish for some reason.
It was basically the band saying: We're not punk. We're The Stranglers, and we'll make whatever music we want.
Supposedly, the first 75,000 copies of the album came with a bonus 7-inch single, which included what many critics consider one of the greatest covers of all time: their version of Walk On By.
Of course, alongside the music, The Stranglers were also developing quite a reputation for their shenanigans.
As we've already established, they were kicked out of Sweden twice, supposedly escorted out by armed guards. That's according to JJ Burnel, anyway. He might have exaggerated slightly, but there were certainly several violent episodes.
One incident came in 1977, when a group of ‘raggare’ – a Swedish subculture associated with American cars and hot-rod culture – attacked the band and their crew.
The raggare weren't particularly fond of hippies, punks or really anyone who wasn't one of them. And The Stranglers happened to be playing in their town.
The group attacked the band, and the crew fought back, supposedly throwing Molotov cocktails at the attackers' cars. The police eventually escorted The Stranglers out of Sweden for their own safety.
The second incident apparently involved Jet Black kicking off at their hotel because he couldn't get any food. Once again, they were escorted to the next plane by armed police.
Their gigs were getting so out of hand that the Hells Angels were even called in as security. That gave us the rather brilliant photograph of JJ Burnel being dragged back onstage by the Angels after getting a little too involved with the crowd.
Then there's the time they allegedly taped a journalist to the Eiffel Tower because they didn't like him.
Burnel recalled the incident in an interview with The Guardian in March 2014:
He turned up at our hotel demanding an interview, so I agreed – if we could do it at the Eiffel Tower. We took his trousers off, gaffer-taped him to one of the girders and left him there to be photographed by Japanese tourists. It was only the first floor. Admittedly, that is 400ft off the ground.
On another occasion, they ended up in a fight with the Sex Pistols because their bassist spat on the floor and JJ didn't like it.
They also performed with strippers in response to being called misogynists. That went down about as well as you'd imagine.
In 1979, one of their managers genuinely suggested that the band should break up. So they fired him.
But perhaps the craziest story of all is the time they decided to take heroin for a year to see what it would do to their music.
Yes, really.
Burnel described it as a creative decision to see what would happen. Jet and Dave supposedly quit after a day, but JJ and Hugh carried on, and things got rather weird.
This was during the making of the album The Gospel According to the Meninblack.
Jet had been reading lots of magazines about UFOs, and the whole band became interested in the subject. Through a haze of heroin, they created a concept album combining alien visits to Earth, the sinister government organisation supposedly enlisted to cover them up – the Men in Black – and Bible verses that they believed revealed the truth.
They were also apparently consuming large amounts of cocaine, hash and LSD during this period.
Their producer eventually walked out during the sessions, leaving the band to finish the record themselves.
They thought it was genius. Not many other people agreed.
The album actually charted reasonably well, reaching number eight, but that was their lowest position to date and probably owed something to the success of their previous work. It was also heavily criticised by both critics and fans.
JJ later suggested that they had ruined themselves making it, flying all over the place to capture different sounds and simply going far too deep in the studio.
They also took a much more electronic direction. Burnel said they were chasing that ‘Giorgio Moroder disco sound’.
Happily, they managed to get themselves back on track in 1982 with an absolute classic from the album La Folie.
Golden Brown is probably their best-known song, and it perfectly demonstrates why The Stranglers were so difficult to categorise.
A lot of people mistakenly think that Golden Brown was originally a Dave Brubeck song, but that's completely false. The rumour apparently came about because of a fan-made Brubeck-Stranglers mash-up posted online. Brubeck had absolutely nothing to do with the song.
The track became their biggest commercial hit, despite sounding very different from most of their other music. It's a perfect example of how willing the band were to experiment and follow their own musical instincts.
And, of course, it wasn't exactly your typical punk song. With its harpsichord, unusual rhythm and mysterious lyrics, it was something else entirely.
With a new record label, The Stranglers found a new vein of form. Throughout the 1980s, they released a series of top 20 albums, continuing to experiment with their sound.
1984's Aural Sculpture introduced a three-piece horn section. By this point, they were moving between post-punk and something approaching synth-pop.
Then came 1986's Dreamtime, which took aim at environmental issues and was generally well received, even in the United States, a market that had largely ignored them for much of their career.
Their next major release was 1990's 10, which featured a great cover of The Kinks' All Day and All of the Night.
This was the last album to feature Hugh Cornwell, who left to pursue a solo career. It was a surprising decision, and perhaps a story worth exploring in its own right.
The band were subsequently dropped by their record label and brought in guitarist John Ellis and singer Paul Roberts to replace Cornwell. This period is sometimes referred to as the Mk2 era.
They released four albums over the following years, but none charted as well as the classic line-up's records, and all received, at best, mixed reviews.
As the 2000s arrived, the band experimented with a four-piece line-up. Baz Warne replaced Ellis on guitar, while Roberts eventually left. In concert, JJ sang the songs he had written, while Warne took on the songs Cornwell had originally sung.
For the last 15 years of their career, The Stranglers continued touring extensively. This was a remarkable feat, considering that several members had experienced some pretty serious health problems. Sometimes members would miss a gig or play only half of it, with other musicians stepping in to help. But they kept on going.
Album releases became less frequent, often consisting of compilation CDs and similar projects, but they continued to put music out. It was a testament to their creative drive.
And they kept going right up until 2025.
Sadly, Dave Greenfield died in 2020 at the age of 71. He had gone into hospital with a heart problem, but contracted Covid and died.
I mentioned earlier that Greenfield was autistic without knowing it, and that's something JJ Burnel discussed in an interview with The Guardian in August 2021:
We always knew Dave was special, but we didn’t realise how special. They’ve got a name for it now. Very high-functioning autistic.
It makes sense when you hear some of the stories about him. Apparently, he was a musical genius but incredibly awkward socially. He struggled with improvising music and hated changes to the setlist, but could programme himself almost like a computer.
Burnel also described Greenfield's approach to the song Genetix in the same Guardian interview in August 2021:
He ‘programmed’ himself. People thought it was a sequencer. It was a human being.
Incredibly, the band's 2021 album Dark Matters, which featured Greenfield's final work, reached number four in the UK charts – their highest placing since 1983.
I'm sure that would have made him smile.
Jet Black sadly passed away in 2022 as well. Rest in peace to both of them.
The Stranglers have continued to tour with a much-changed line-up, carrying on the legacy of a band that never quite fitted into any one musical category.
And perhaps that's exactly why they were so successful. They shared punk's aggression and attitude, but never felt the need to follow its rules. They could be aggressive, experimental, melodic, electronic, strange and occasionally completely ridiculous – sometimes all on the same album.
They weren't The Clash or the Sex Pistols. They were The Stranglers, and they did things their own way.
If you would rather watch these stories than read them, check out my YouTube channel!











Comments